As a major trade partner of the US, the increasing value of the Canadian dollar against the US dollar has put a dent on export growth. Furthermore, the correlation between crude prices and the Canadian dollar have diverged over the course of the first quarter, despite the fact that oil production remains a crucial component to the Canadian economy. In the second quarter, a few big factors loom large for the Canadian Dollar, namely exports, domestic growth, the next big trend in commodity prices and the reliability of US demand.
Exports Still the Linchpin of Growth, But For How
Long?
Over the past four years, the Commodity Boom in oil has been
the primary driver of the price action in the Canadian dollar. However this boom
came to a screaming halt in 2006, when oil prices hit a high of $78.40. By
mid January 2007, prices ran below $50 a barrel, before rebounding in
February. The downtrend in commodity prices drove the current account
surplus down from C$5.0 billion to C$3.0 billion in the fourth quarter and the
Canadian dollar along with it. More recently, though, monthly measurements of
the trade account look slightly more promising, with the January reading of the
goods and services account rebounding back to C$6.35 billion. The prior weakness
of the Canadian dollar played a major role in the turnaround in the overall
economy, eventually taking the CAD to 1.1501 against the US dollar from prior
lows of 1.1875. However the renewed strength of the currency could also be
what ends up killing the economy. If the Canadian dollar strengthens further
throughout the second quarter as it has done in the first, the country’s primary
trading partner – the US – may cut back on purchases of Canadian products and
undermine the strength of the economy as a whole. Furthermore, should
commodity prices continue to ease back, the value of goods shipped out of the
country could easily decline and erode Canada’s trade balance.
Employment the Key to Domestic Demand-Led Expansion
As
foreign demand for Canadian products have started to dwindle, domestic
consumption has slowly started to pick up as the booming oil sector provides
jobs for much of the population of the Alberta region. The improvements in
employment growth have become more widespread as well, as the 54.9K jump in net
employment in March saw an acceleration of hiring in the services sector.
However, this led to a slowdown in wage growth to 2.2 percent from 2.8 percent,
as workers were hired in regions outside of oil-rich areas where work-shortages
have driven up pay. Regardless, the effects of a stronger labor market have
started to reflect in the broader economy, with retail sales (excluding autos)
rising 0.3 percent in the month of January after surging 1.9 percent the month
prior. Additionally, IVEY PMI rose to 67.3 as businesses indicated
improvements in not only employment, but prices as well. Furthermore, the
leading economic indicator for the country rose 0.7 percent – the sharpest
increase since June 2004 – as optimistic sentiment led equity shares, new orders
for durable goods, and furniture sales higher.
On the other hand, the shift in the Canadian labor market towards the services sector has been to the detriment of manufacturing. While this is generally a natural progression that has been witnessed in the UK and Europe – but most abundantly in the US – the Canadian manufacturing sector is still seen as a crucial part of the economy given the importance of exports. In fact, the easing in Canadian GDP in January to 0.1 percent – the slowest pace in four months – was drawn down primarily by manufacturing, which plunged 1 percent despite improvements in the trade report and the Ivey PMI report. Overall, the weaker figures could keep the Bank of Canada on edge regarding the downside risks of the manufacturing sector to expansion.
Hot Inflation – A One Time Event?
Since the Bank of
Canada halted its series of seven-consecutive rate hikes in May 2006, inflation
has come to the forefront once again as traders speculate on the future of
monetary policy. With a self-defined target rate of 2.0 percent growth,
annual measurements have rebounded in the first quarter as the BoC’s own
measurement of core CPI has surged to 2.4 percent – well above the central
bank’s target. However, BoC Governor David Dodge said following the release,
"Obviously it was more than most economists, including ourselves, were
expecting...There could well have been some special factors in that, and we're
going to have to evaluate, when we get a little more, whether there's any change
there or not," effectively cautioning against putting too much emphasis on data
from one month alone. Nevertheless, should price pressures fail to let up, the
BoC will have little choice but to pay heed to CPI reports, which will likely
keep the central bank’s benchmark rate at 4.25 percent.
US Growth and Canada – Waiting for the Other Shoe to
Drop?
The close ties between Canada and the US are undeniable, as 75
percent of Canadian exports go to the US, creating a unique dynamic for the
currency pair. Although growth in the US has been widely anticipated to slow
substantially on the back of a slump in the housing sector, economic data has
yet to consistently prove that this is happening. GDP has indeed slowed to 2.5
percent from 5.6 percent in early 2006, but the labor market has remained strong
as March Non-Farm Payrolls surprisingly gained by 180K , driving the
unemployment rate to a five year low of 4.1 percent. Furthermore, US purchases
of Canadian goods have yet to fall back. Consider this: the Canadian trade
surplus widened to C$6.35 billion - the largest since December 2005 – as exports
hit a record. Moreover, the trade balance with the US alone widened to C$8.73
billion in January from C$7.93 billion – the biggest surplus since January 2006.
Overall, growth in Canada should remain supported by their southern neighbor so
long as a major US slowdown is avoided. However, if US growth does become a
concern like it did for part of the first quarter, we have seen how the Canadian
dollar can behave as a result. The currency completely shrugged off the
rise in oil on the greater fear that a shortfall in exports to the US would be
far more damaging to economic growth.
What Happened to Oil?
While the consumer would be the
most reliable driver of growth for the Canadian economy going forward, a second
wave in commodity-driven exports could also reignite growth. The key to a
raw-material led rebound is the volatile crude oil. However, while Canada
remains the largest source of oil the United States, the USD/CAD negative
correlation with crude prices has slowly and inexplicably weakened. This was
particularly surprising given the recent surge in oil above $68/bbl after Iran
took 15 British soldiers hostage and crude’s subsequent decline after their
release. Nevertheless, it will be important to watch how the oil-Canadian dollar
correlation plays out, as crude has little potential of falling out of style and
prices could eventually move in sync one again.
Conclusion
The extent of the inter-dependence between
Canada and the US will likely dominate the fundamental direction of the USD/CAD
currency pair into the second quarter of 2007. Should US growth actually
flounder in the near future as many analysts and economists have forecast, the
Canadian economy will likely suffer the burden of constrained demand from its
largest export market. Furthermore, more traditional issues will take root for
the Canadian dollar as domestically-driven growth factors like consumer
spending, housing construction and factory activity will play an integral role
in gauging the direction of locally-led demand. Finally, a close eye will
always be kept on crude and other commodity prices for a strong return in the
correlation with USDCAD spot.
Technical USD/CAD Outlook
The USD/CAD rallied to the channel resistance that
we discussed in our 2007 first quarter forecast and has turned down in what may
be the 5th of the 5th wave in the entire bearish sequence that began in 2002 at
1.6189. Coming under 1.1457 would eliminate the alternate count that
labels the decline from 1.1879 as a 4th wave correction and increase the odds
that a new low will be registered (below 1.0927). Sentiment continues to
improve following the bearish extreme that was registered in mid-January.
For the week that ended January 12th, net speculative positioning (COT) was at
-84,906 and that number has been cut to -35,165 (as of the report that was
released on April 3rd). Interestingly, wave structures and COT readings
for other currencies point to future weakness against the USD. The CAD is
the exception, thus the best trading opportunities going forward may be in the
CAD crosses, particularly the
EUR/CAD.